An uproar was recently started in reference to some privacy concerns about the new release from Google, Google Buzz. One of the first to sound the alarm was a blogger who was quite explicit about disliking some of its default options (and by explicit I mean “NSFW language” explicit, the post is here) which prompted some quick changes from Google.  In order to start using Buzz, you have to create/modify your Google public profile which will appear next to all of your activity in the Buzz feed.  By default, the public profile would display all those you follow. Chances are you’ve followed everyone in your contact list, so you just made your whole contact list public.  Now in the new behavior:

A box titled “How do you want to appear to others” will now include a check-box that says “Show the list of people I’m following and the list of people following me on my public profile.” To hide your followers, click the box, or click the “View and edit the people you follow” to customize your account.

The interesting thing here to me is that Buzz is essentially a service like Facebook or Twitter, designed to let other folks know what you are up to.  The fact that there is a privacy uproar around it is somewhat amusing, because it is designed to provide the opposite of privacy – to provide your followers information about what you are doing.  If you don’t want to share this information, don’t use Google Buzz!

I’ll enlist a famous quote from Scott McNealy, then CEO of Sun Microsystems: “You have zero privacy anyway. Get over it.”

It is amusing to me what people – especially young people – are willing to post online.  As a child, my parents once told me that once you say something you can’t take it back.  In today’s Internet-connected age, this holds true and is even more significant: once you say something online, hundreds if not thousands of people will see it instantly, and potentially billions of people will be able to track it down in archives, Google searches, the wayback machine, or in countless other ways.  Be careful what you share online.  Be careful what you say.  It might–probably will–come back to haunt you.

4 thoughts on “Google Buzz, Privacy, and You

  1. Grecs says:

    Good points however I think the issue is that even if you choose NOT to “check out” Buzz when it first presents you an option, it still enables it. Then it links your Reader and Picassa apps automatically. And it seems to auto follow/allow follows. And alot of the meta data (e.g., contacts) can be openly viewed on your profile. Of course all this occurs even if you choose NOT to enable it.

    Buzz should have been rolled out using their “invite” model and all the initial options should be private by default.

  2. Peter Hesse says:

    Grecs – I didn’t realize that. That is irresponsible for sure.

    Also, did you see this comic?

  3. Grecs says:

    Yeah, saw that. Pretty good!

  4. Hello there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it is really informative. I’m gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

Comments are closed.